Rubric Optimization Report

Initial Rubric: ['Is this a well-written essay for an 8th grade student?']

Target Kappa: 0.7

Optimization Process

Final Results

Best Rubric: ['Does the essay present a clear opinion on how computers impact society (either positively or negatively)?', 'Does the essay provide at least two specific and distinct ways computers affect society?', 'Are there relevant examples or personal experiences that support the main points?', "Is the main argument about computers' impact on society consistent throughout the essay?", 'Does the essay demonstrate a basic understanding of computers and their role in society?', "Is the overall message about computers' societal impact understandable, regardless of writing quality?", 'Ignore spelling mistakes, grammar errors, and placeholders like @PERSON1 or @LOCATION2', 'Focus on the content and argument rather than writing style or structure']

Best Kappa (Representative Set): 0.6974645466265579

Final Kappa (Evaluation Set): 0.04761904761904767